Write Science Blog / Oili Kiikkilä

I write this blog with the aim to help researchers to write and publish scientific articles. The issues arise mostly from my experience in reading articles that I have got to edit. Secondly, they arise from researchers' efforts to publish articles.

I use real cases as examples, but I change the text so that the authors cannot be recognized.

These are my personal opinions, and anyone is free to disagree. We can discuss all aspects related to scientific writing and publishing.

I encourage researchers to share their experiences about review process in different journals. How long did it take, did you feel the review fare? Feel free to comment here.

I also encourage everyone to write their experience about the journal to SciRev sites https://scirev.org/.
Within these free and non-commercial sites, you can share your experience with the scientific review process and select an efficient journal for submitting your manuscripts.

I'm pleased to hear if you find these posts useful or interesting. If you have any ideas you would like me to share my experience, please contact.

If you would like to subscribe to my mailing list to get the blog posts, please send me a mail.
Monday, May 14, 2018, 12:55

A PlosOne review process of one article is worth of sharing. I do not remember the times taken correctly, but all this took very long, several months regardless of continuous asking about the process.

The editor told to each inquiry that he had not found any reviewers. It is good to mention that the manuscript dealt with a rare subject. Even so rare that during the writing, it had been difficult to find ‘enough’ relevant articles to be referred. However, on the other hand, the subject was pretty general and the methods were relatively simple microbiology and, in my understanding, it should not have been so extremely difficult to find any reviewers.

Finally, the reviews came. There were three of those, and none of them suggested rejection. Each of them suggested revision, one minor, and the two other reviewers wrote that the topic is important and emerging. Two latter reviews were of high quality and the reviewers seemed to know about the subject. However, the editor rejected the manuscript. The editor required additional experiments, although he should have understood that this was a field study and not possible to make any new experiments. None of the reviewers suggested more experiments, they suggested minor-moderate changes in writing.

The oddest thing to happen was still to come. It appeared later, that there had been one more review that had been very positive. We came to know about this review, because the reviewer in question contacted the author and told about it. This reviewer had been studying the same research subject. We had no reason to believe that this positive review would not have been on the editor’s table.

The only explanation I can imagine for this is that because the subject was really rare, it could have been presumed that it will gain only few citations in the near future. PlosOne is a journal wanting to increase its impact factor (although all journals want, of course) and therefore, it may keep the possibility to gain citations as one important principle to assess the manuscripts.

Finally, the manuscript was pretty fast accepted elsewhere.

If you want to share your review experiences, go to SciRev sites and write them there. You can also compare different journals on the sites and read experiences. 


cheap essay writi(...) wrote:
Friday, May 18, 2018, 13:27
Well, it is very nice if you do share stuff like this but there is much more than you can do here, we are now working on same subject right for the moment because online essay review would give you an idea how to make your work more elegant and professional, we have been working on this niche for the last couple of years and we hope fresh content can help you to improve your ranking. I not only appreciate this post, but I give unlimited thumb ups to your blog as every student can find help from this blog. I recommend this blog to all the students specially looking for the Psychology programs. If you are looking for the cheap essay writing service . it would also be a good blog. Thanks for sharing such interesting and informative article. I really appreciate your work, Keep it up and you will be very successful in future.
(*) Required fields
Contact | | Blog

EcoSCI Edit, Helsinki, Finland, EU
Copyright (EcoSCI Edit) 2016 - 2018, All Rights Reserved